"The very concept of objective truth is fading out of the world" - George Orwell


Showing posts with label MLB. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MLB. Show all posts

Monday, August 5, 2013

The Spinelessness Of Major League Baseball

Today the suspensions in the MLB Biogenesis investigation were handed down.  12 players were suspended for 50 games, including some prominent players on contending teams.  But the big fish, Alex Rodriguez, was suspended for the remainder of this season and through the 2014 season.  Many, including MLB themselves, are crowing about the success of drug testing and coming down hard on offenders within the league.  However, every fan of professional baseball should be furious at yet another opportunity lost due to the spinelessness of Bud Selig and the commissioner's office.

From everything the public has been told, Alex Rodriguez, an admitted steroid user from 2001-03, not only was a client of Biogenesis, but recruited players to the facility, and once the investigation began, did his best to obstruct the inquiry to the best of his ability.

For weeks we have heard that MLB has been in negotiations with Rodriguez on a suspension settlement.  It seems that MLB's major concern is Rodriguez appealing the suspension and having the matter heard by an arbitrator, and if a settlement is agreed upon with him, they can avoid arbitration all together.  They successfully negotiated a similar suspension agreement with All Star Ryan Braun earlier this summer.

But my question, and the question every baseball fan should be asking is, why is MLB negotiating AT ALL with A-Rod?

This is not a situation where there are alleged violations, in which players can mitigate their punishments by negotiating, or MLB can forgo a possible publicity nightmare by the player being vindicated through arbitration.  MLB supposedly has mountains of evidence against Rodriguez, as well as other players.  This is the reason that Braun agreed to a settlement rather than continue his Lance Armstrong type defiance.

To negotiate with Rodriguez just helps Rodriguez, not MLB.

What they should have done, and if the commissioner had any backbone, would be suspend Rodriguez for life.

He is a repeat offender who cheated and defiantly attempted to cover it up.  With all of the evidence they have against him, there is no reason why MLB shouldn't have made an example out him and kicked him out of the league for good.  This would be a huge deterrent for other players that if they are caught there will be major consequences.

As it stands now Rodriguez will take a year off and be allowed to return to the field to collect the remaining millions on his astronomical contract.  Some penalty.  If I were an up and coming player (and didn't care about my future health and the integrity of the game) I wouldn't see any reason NOT to take PED's, "earn" myself a massive contract, and if I get caught, oh well.  I go on a little vacation and return to collect 85-90% of my huge contract.

And why should MLB fear going to arbitration with Rodriguez?  They should welcome it.  They will be able to present all of the evidence they have against him and force Rodriguez to defend himself.  They should be thrilled if he challenges any suspension to open up the process and show what a blatant cheater he is and how the sport will not stand for it.

Unfortunately MLB has wimped out yet again, and has done nothing to preserve the long term validity of the game.

Shame on you Bud Selig.

And in case you're scoring at home:

Betting on baseball (Pete Rose) or accused of fixing games (Joe Jackson) - Lifetime ban

Being a brazen cheater and liar who spits in the face of the league that has given him millions - 211 games suspension.

Bravo MLB, Bravo.

Thursday, May 9, 2013

It's Time For A Replay Umpire In MLB

At this point I'm sure every baseball fan has seen the home run that wasn't in Wednesday night's game between the Oakland A's and the Cleveland Indians.  Adam Rosales of the A's hit a home run that should have tied the score in the top of the 9th inning, however it was ruled a double on the field.  After a lengthy review that clearly showed the ball clearing the fence, the umpires still got the call wrong allowing the Indians to hold on to for a 4-3 win.



This is not the first time umpires have blown a call, and it certainly won't be the last.  But as I argued in my last post, it's time for Major League Baseball to stop kowtowing to umpires and embrace the available technology in today's society and get the calls right.

Every year the talk of expanding replay swirls, but MLB has been the one major sport to be hesitant about fully enforcing it.  As of now the only reviewable play is whether a ball clears the fence or not.  This reluctance is fueled by purists who insist the game will be harmed if the "human element" i.e. the umpires, are taken out of the game.  This argument is pure lunacy when the prerogative of MLB and the umpires should be to get the call right.

But as we saw Wednesday night, even with replay, umpires can still get a call wrong despite clear, indisputable evidence.

To correct this issue MLB should institute a review umpire who is capable of reviewing key plays during a game, such as if a ball is fair or foul, a home run or not, as well as base running calls.  The umpires should still be employed to make the calls on the field, including balls and strikes (which shouldn't be reviewable) but these specific plays should be reviewed by the review umpire, and if a play was called incorrectly, he can buzz down to the field immediately to have it overturned.

In addition a replay umpire will negate long delays in the game for reviews, as seen in Wednesday's game, which is often sighted by those opposed to replay review.

This will also give the teams and fans more transparency into how these calls are made.  As Oakland manager Bob Melvin said after the game, he had no idea what angles the umpires were looking at let alone what device they were using to view the play in question.  As it is right now the umpires disappear into the bowels of the stadium to look at the replays.  Even the NFL has the intelligence to keep their officials on the field during their reviews, in full sight of the teams and fans.

Despite there being 162 games in a season, every game does count.  We only need to look to last season in the American League West, which was decided on the last day of the season to prove this point.  This one game may come back to haunt Oakland, which would be tragic.

This seems like an obvious fix, but seeing the massive ego's of MLB umpires, coupled with a commissioner who lacks any guts to expand replay, it may take a lot more than a blown game in early May to get the ball rolling on real and long overdue change to America's pastime.